Traditional Publishing vs. Self-Publishing: Which Path is Right for You?

As an aspiring non-fiction author, one of the most critical decisions you'll make is whether to pursue traditional publishing or self-publishing. Each path has its advantages and challenges, and the best choice depends on your individual goals, resources, and preferences. In this comprehensive guide, we'll compare traditional publishing and self-publishing, examining factors such as creative control, royalties, and marketing to help you make the best decision for your unique situation.

1. Creative Control

Traditional Publishing:

When authors choose to publish through traditional means, they must often relinquish some creative control to their publishers. Editors may offer feedback on the manuscript, resulting in significant changes to the work. The traditional publisher ultimately decides on the book's presentation, including cover design, font selection, and formatting. While this can be frustrating for authors who desire complete control over their work, it can also be beneficial as publishers have extensive experience in marketing.


Self-publishing empowers authors by granting them complete creative control over their work. This means that you, as the author, can make all the decisions regarding your manuscript, including the cover design, formatting, and marketing strategy. With self-publishing, you have the freedom to bring your unique vision to life without any compromises, giving you the opportunity to create a book that truly reflects your voice and vision.

2. Royalties and Earnings

Traditional Publishing:

Traditionally published authors usually receive an advance payment against future royalties. Once the advance has been earned, authors receive a percentage of book sales, typically between 10-15% for print books and 25% for ebooks. However, these percentages may vary depending on factors such as the publisher, book format, and sales channels.


Self-published authors generally receive higher royalty rates, often between 60-70% for ebooks and 40-60% for print-on-demand books. However, there are no advances, and authors must cover all upfront costs associated with producing and marketing their books.

3. Marketing and Promotion

Traditional Publishing:

In traditional publishing, the publisher typically handles some aspects of marketing and promotion, such as securing book reviews, organizing book tours, and coordinating publicity efforts. However, authors are still expected to be active in promoting their books and building their author platforms.


Self-published authors are responsible for all marketing and promotional efforts. This includes building an author platform, leveraging social media, obtaining book reviews, and creating promotional materials. While this can be time-consuming, it also allows authors to develop a tailored marketing strategy that aligns with their goals and target audience for their self-published books.

4. Time to Publication

Traditional Publishing:

The traditional publishing process can be lengthy, often taking 1-2 years or more from the time a manuscript is accepted until the book is released. This includes time for editing, cover design, marketing efforts, and distribution.


Self-publishing is generally a faster route to publication. Once your manuscript is ready, the self-publishing process can take as little as a few weeks to a few months, depending on factors such as editing, formatting, and cover design.

5. Credibility and Prestige

Traditional Publishing:

Traditionally published books often carry a certain level of prestige and credibility, as they have been vetted by industry professionals. This can lead to greater recognition, award eligibility, and opportunities for speaking engagements and media appearances.


While self-publishing has gained acceptance in recent years, some readers and industry professionals may still view self-published works as less credible than traditionally published titles. However, with high-quality editing, design, and marketing efforts, self-published authors can achieve success and garner respect within the industry.


Deciding whether to pursue traditional publishing or self-publishing is a highly individualized choice, shaped by factors such as your unique objectives, personal preferences, and available resources. It's important to thoroughly comprehend the distinctions between these two options and thoughtfully evaluate which path is the right fit for you. Specifically, you'll need to weigh the pros and cons of the traditional publishing route, which involves partnering with a publishing company, against the benefits and drawbacks of self-publishing.




Address: 447 Broadway, 2nd Floor Suite #2056, New York, 10013, United States

Authors On Mission. All rights reserved.