Secrets Tips from the Editor’s Desk for a Standout Manuscript

You may be curious about the magic formula of one manuscript to shine out in a sea of submissions on an editor's desk at any reputable book publishing company. The solution is usually in learning to see things from the complicated viewpoint of those who have a decided hand in turning your writing into this season's hottest seller. As an aspiring author, one needs to not only be proficient in their craft but also understand what the editors are looking for and the common mistakes that can cause your work to end up on the rejection pile. In this blog, we unveil the secrets of professional editors and a practical guide on how to do it right that will transform your manuscript from great to remarkable. So, let's go into the publishing industry and see how to make your manuscript stand out in front of those who matter a lot.

Understanding an Editor's Perspective

Ultimately, an editor's purpose within the publishing process can be likened to that of a gifted gardener who cultivates and reshapes a manuscript into its most optimal form. The unsung heroes of the writing process are the editors who act and trim away excessive words and ideas to create a smooth flow from start to finish. They are taught to read a text through the lenses of literary criticism and with an objective eye, focusing not only on grammar but also on productions such as plot organization/cohesion and characterization occurrences that encompass more than just poor syntax.

The perspective of an editor usually contrasts greatly with that of a writer. That’s why it’s important to plan ahead for your book before writing It because Depending on a writer's active involvement in their work and his emotionally charged attitude toward its creation, an editor comes across the text with cool professional detachment. They are very sensitive to the market dynamics, needs of the audience as well as economic potentiality a book has got. The writer might miss or underestimate.

For an author, finding a perspective in agreement with the editor is very essential. It is not only about creating an appealing story but also about describing it in a way that fits successfully to the editor's understanding of how this would be engaging for readers and survive the competition. Such a balance between creative expression and marketable content is what makes the manuscript turn from being just an individual project to a book.

Key Qualities Editors Look For

When going through the stacks of manuscripts, editors look for certain qualities that make some submissions stand out. Originality and newness stand out; a manuscript with novelty or a fresh approach to an old topic is quickly noticed by the editor. This uniqueness may come from a new plot, an odd character, or a fresh narrative technique, with the editors typically desiring something that stands out in the middle of monotony.

Another important point is the strong character development. The main element of any success stories are the characters, that editors curate to find realistic personalities that develop from being complex intricately woven in the context throughout a story. The desire is that the characters come alive and remain with a person for some time, even after one has finished reading it.

A well-structured plot is also very important. It has a clear and comprehensible plot that is coherent as well as thrilling. Editors admire the plots that are carefully developed and executed, comparing a good plot to an assembled puzzle where every piece has its own place.

In genres such as fantasy or historical fiction, vivid settings and world-building are especially critical. The creation of a very lifelike and also compelling setting is quintessential as it should be able to captivate the reader. Most editors hold that the scene-setting is not merely a framed background but one of its own making.

An engaging writing style is always a plus. A manuscript that showcases a unique, confident writing style with an engaging tone and rhythm that suits the story is highly valued. The belief is that engaging writing doesn't just tell a story; it invites the reader into it.

Editors also look for emotional resonance. They find stories that touch many people emotionally, whether they make them happy, sad or afraid. The sentiment is that the books you remember for years to come are those which make you feel something, and thus emotional depth helps in connecting the readers with success stories.

Finally, marketability and audience appeal are also considered. Beyond the creative elements, editors also evaluate the marketability of a manuscript – its potential appeal to its intended audience and how it fits within current market trends. A common consideration is looking for books that fill a gap in the market or have a clear audience.

While these qualities are significant, they don't guarantee success. Each editor has their own preferences, and publishing decisions often involve a combination of these factors and the current market dynamics.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Such mistakes are quite common in the manuscripts that editors usually face, and often, they can decrease the chance of publishing. A lack of proper formatting is the biggest problem; manuscripts that do not follow the general formatting rules are difficult to read and usually end up being discarded. To circumvent this problem, authors should learn some basic formatting practices, such as using a legible font type, proper spacing margins, and also consistent paragraph alignment.

One of the most common mistakes is insufficient proofreading. Wrongly spelled and grammatically incorrect manuscripts reflect poor professionalism. Authors need to spare some time for proofreading, or they can hire professional editing service providers, as it can help them in correcting their manuscript before sending a copy to any book publishing company.

Manuscripts can also lose their appeal due to the trite storylines and overused tropes. Editors want something new and very unusual. However, the authors need to add a lot of originality and be very creative to shaping the future of reading. Wider reading can help to identify the common tropes and narratives, as well as generate new content that is more original.

By focusing on these elements – formatting, proofreading and also originality - authors can make their manuscripts much more appealing to the editors.


Aspiring authors, this advice from experienced editors will help you to create clean manuscripts that stand a much better chance of getting published. However, recall that all great books begin with a single well-written manuscript. For more help and customized guidance, contact the Authors on Mission. Join our email list, participate in a webinar series, or schedule a consultation to advance your own writing.

Your literary journey awaits!




Address: 447 Broadway, 2nd Floor Suite #2056, New York, 10013, United States

Authors On Mission. All rights reserved.